The Hall of Fame Shutout

the politics of glory, dept.

The "correct" 2012 HOF ballot would have had 8-10 names on it.  James' ballot consisted of, 

.

Raines, Rocket, Biggio, Piazza, Edgar Martinez, Trammell, McGriff, McGwire.   Maybe another one or two. ..I dunno.

We sent him this question, this morning:

.

 

You had eight names for us on your 2012 HOF ballot and "maybe one or two more."  I think I've read everything of yours OTHER than the Hall of Fame works -- just have never been super interested in the subject -- but maybe you'd be willing to provide an 'executive summary' of the political aspects for those readers who missed the books.

... The sportswriters threw a shutout, and seemed to enjoy throwing the shutout.  They seem to relish going on TV and wallowing in the reasons that Biggio or Edgar or Piazza can reasonably be kept out, and they seem to relish a discussion of why they should appropriately hold this power over the players, and they seem to relish this "first ballot HOF'er" distinction and relish keeping it away from guys like Biggio.

... the motivation here is honestly opaque to me, but whatever it is, it seems to please the Hall itself, also.  Care to let us newbies in on the joke?  :- )  

Here's where my naivete really bites me, because I honestly can't imagine what gratification the writers get from excluding Craig Biggio from the Hall of Fame.

They could try to argue that it was purely intellectual.  Nobody's buying that one, babe, not with this ballot.  James has EIGHT names going in.  Something emotional's going on, and that something emotional is not friendly between sportswriter and player.  But what did Craig Biggio or Edgar or Fred McGriff ever do to anybody?

And none of this seems to go on with the NFL or NBA halls of fame.  You don't see writers going on with this precious little discussion about how sanctified the NFL hall is and how important it is for Jerry Rice not to go in on the first ballot when that should truly be reserved for Chuck Bednarik.  It's something that goes on in baseball, and that truly goes over my head.

Even Geoff Baker, who is not petty or small-minded at all, not envious of players, etc., has weighed in strongly on the side that it's good to have a shutout this year.  This adds to Dr. D's confusion.

This year?!  James had 8-10 names going in.  But, of course, Bill James doesn't have a ballot.  They wouldn't want him contaminating the election process.

Maybe YOU guys can let me in on the joke.  :- )

 

Supercut Of The Insulting Nicknames From "Archer"

FX's "Archer" returns this Thursday for its fourth season, thus surviving three more seasons than I ever gave it credit to survive. (Seriously I am amazed this show lasted, and so so thankful). Slacktory decided they needed to make a supercut, and I am so glad they did. Here is a nice mix of all the insulting nicknames from the classic show, which you should really be watching. (The first two seasons are on Netflix Streaming, and the third came out on DVD last week.)

Sonics Tradition

of leagues, cities, and owners

.

On the subject of NBA franchise relocation, James had an intriguing way to organize our thoughts:

.

 

Personally, I don't think it's important to preserve [statistical] records, because we'll adapt to the new records, just like we adapted to huge strikeout changes, etc, (or NFL going from 14- to 16-game season and eventually 18). Even so, going to 8-inning game will radically change bullpen usage, but, we've seen that over the past 30 years anyway.
Asked by: tangotiger
Answered: 1/14/2013
Well. ...philosophically, you and I share a predisposition in favor of change; I think we're both inclined to believe that baseball hurts itself more than it helps itself by its fear of change.  
 
But at the same time, it does not follow that all changes are good changes, or that there is no value in tradition.   Indeed, almost the ENTIRE value of a sports franchise is in its traditions.   You and I could design a game which is as entertaining to watch as baseball or football, but were a league to be launched based on that game, its revenues in Year One would be less than 1% of the revenues of the NFL or MLB.    The other 99% is accounted for traditions.  
 
The value in the franchises is in the traditions which bind its fan base to the team.    While I agree that baseball needs to be open to change, I also think that it needs to be not TOO anxious to change.  

.

This is a thought-provoking suggestion -- that 99% of the Seahawks' shirt sales* are really because of a contextual backdrop.  The fact that they're playing in the NFL(TM), the league of Lombardi and Walsh and Unitas and etc., and the investment that sons and fathers have made over the years -- this is the fabric of fan loyalty and intensity.

Compare the value of a product's "brand"; the Coca-Cola "brand" is worth 60-something billion.  The memories, feelings, and attitudes are themselves the marketable product.

Obviously, most of this is true.  You could build a USFL team to play in Portland, and it might have great players, but it's not going to have anything that we value about a Felix Hernandez - Albert Pujols matchup on Friday night.  This would be true even if Felix and Pujols jumped to the USFL.*

Continuing:

...........

 

A question I've never gotten my ethical bearings on -- the potential move now of the Sacramento Kings to Seattle. As you see it, should a Seattle basketball fan feel sheepish about the situation in general? The new franchise will, or won't, be (or feel like) the Sonics on a civically psychic level?
 
Just noodlin' ... certainly you have a strong perspective on the general issue of sports teams relocating, the ethic that applies, and the tendency for it to turn out to be emotionally satisfying, or to manifest good karma so to speak, or not ...
Asked by: jemanji
Answered: 1/14/2013
Well, it relates to the value in tradition, which I was just talking about with Tom.     There was a 20-year period, 1953-1972, in which baseball franchises hopped around chasing bigger markets.   This was period of near-zero growth in baseball attendance--certainly the worst 20-year period growth record in baseball history (I think the exact worst is 1948-1968, and I believe that PER GAME attendance actually declined significantly over than 20-year period).   Eventually baseball realized that it was hurting itself by allowing franchises to move around willy-nilly, and put a stop to it.   
 
This is not to say, either, that a team should NEVER move.    A league should never allow the OWNER of a team to move the team for his own personal reasons--as, for example, Irsay did in moving the Colts out of Baltimore.  The team, in a more enlightened sense than legal ownership, belongs not to the person who has purchased the team, but to its fans, to the city, and to the league.    It damages a league for the league to allow the "owner", as one of the rights of ownership, to severe those other ties.    Nothing in the law, nothing in the concept of "ownership", says that an owner has the right to make that decision without considering the long-term best interests of the league. 
.

James acknowledges that the LEAGUE gets half of the credit for the psychic "brand", and the CITY the other half.  It's a Lennon-McCartney partnership, and he sees (transitory) owners as little more than band managers in this equation.

He also calls into question whether it should be a "right of ownership" to move a team, given that it uproots the psychic value (and thus the brand and cashflow) of the franchise.

You might protest, well, the Oklahoma Thunder became marketable pretty quick.  Yes, that's why James acknowledges the league -- the NBA, not Clay Bennett -- as equal partner in this equation with Seattle.  Kevin Durant is scoring 30 a game in the contextual backdrop of the Kareem and Magic and Bird league.

You might ask, why didn't the NBA care more about tradition in Seattle?  James has great disdain for Larry Stern.

.

 

I don't care about the 'legal' aspect; it just strikes me as historically inaccurate to say that they are one and the same franchise, which really isn't true.
Asked by: jimmybart
Answered: 1/15/2013
Well. . .why isn't it true?    It's like adoption.    Aren't you basically saying that adoptive parents are lying when they say this is "their" child, when it really isn't their child?    If I refer to my mother-in-law as "Mom", is that lying?   Why is it in any sense deceptive to refer to a Seattle basketball team as the Sonics?
 
 
So this has led us to a philosophical position that the NBA owes it to Seattle to return the Sonics to them; the travesty will be that they were ever gone for a few years.  The way in which the NBA -- a weasel organization -- chooses to do that, is a different subject.
 
Finally:
 
I agree about the "legal" parameter not being relevant. In terms of the "continuity" of a franchise, I treat the Nationals as a break from Expos. Washington didn't honor the retired numbers (at least for the first several years), Montreal fans didn't follow the team, and the ownership obviously had no continuity. And if Montreal would have gotten a new team today, they'd honor their past history completely. The right thing is to let involved fans judge the continuity, and not have some legal or formulaic bean-counter process to decide how fans of Montreal and Washington should decide on the continuity.
Asked by: tangotiger
Answered: 1/15/2013
That's entirely right, I think.  Good to be able to agree with you about something. . ..I think we've missed like four in a row.  

 

Two Dogs Interrupt Soccer Game With Play Time

In Turkey, two Golden Retrievers took it upon themselves to rally their team together under the band of unity and togetherness, pushing their home team to victory. Okay, not really all that, mostly they just ran around being cute interrupting people's serious sport.

2012 Pitching Leaderboards -- "Production Prevention"

Denying XBH and walks

Here come more leaderboards in the pitching categories.

Once again, we note: Unlike hitters, I do not put an age cap on pitchers.  So some older guys will be mixed in.  The minimum number of batters faced is 100.

***

Stat: Production Prevention, which is (XBH + BB)/PA or BF [same thing] (expressed as percent)

Rule of thumb:  Those who have been following along know that I look for hitters to produce extra-base hits and walks as the basis for their "production" of offense, and, conversely, I look for pitchers to be able to prevent hitters from doing as much.  Pitchers do well to keep XBH + BB to under 14% of batters faced.  It's interesting to keep in mind that strikeouts do not impact this particular stat at all.

***

Starters:

  1. Erasmo Ramirez (22) 10.2%
  2. George Mieses (21) 10.8% (also reliever)
  3. Trevor Miller (21) 11.1%
  4. Jordan Pries (22) 11.2%
  5. Stephen Landazuri (20) 11.5%
  6. Robert Shore (23) 12.1% (also reliever)
  7. Chris Sorce (24) 13.3%
  8. Anthony Fernandez (22) 13.4%
  9. Dylan "Sharkie" Unsworth (19) 13.4%
  10. Blake Beavan (22) 13.8%

***

Relievers:

[Technical non-qualfier (96 batters faced):  Matt Brazis (22) 7.3%]

  1. Carter Capps (21) 9.2%
  2. Kyle Hunter (23) 9.8%
  3. David Colvin (23) 10.2%
  4. Brian Moran (23) 11.8%
  5. Bobby LaFromboise (26) 11.9%
  6. David Pauley (29) 12.1%
  7. Grady Wood (22) 12.7%
  8. David Holman (22) 12.9%
  9. Austin Hudson (24) 12.9%
  10. Stephen Shackleford (23) 13.3%

***

Below age-arc (young for level) pitchers:

  1. Capps (21) 9.2%
  2. Ramirez (22) 10.2%
  3. Brandon Maurer (21) 14.1%
  4. Tyler Pike (18) 14.3%
  5. Victor Sanchez (17) 14.3%

***

Notes:  Besides the cool thing that guys like Capps and Brazis, who were striking out the world, also were good at preventing XBH and walks, probably the most notable number belongs to Mieses.

He's been pushed pretty hard up the ladder (Clinton at 20, High Desert at 21), and his numbers haven't been super-exciting along the way, but to be right up there with Erasmo on this list, and ahead of Anthony Fernandez and Sharkie Unsworth (both of whom are better known for damage-control than "stuff"), is pretty interesting.

If you've been following my stuff, then you already have an inkling about Jordan Pries and Stephen Landazuri, but Trevor Miller is also trying barge into that group.  The 2011 40th-round pick was excellent in five starts in High Desert at the end of the year.

Man Watching Police Chase Gets Front Row Seating

Who hasn't watched a police chase and thought, "I wonder if that is near where I live?" Well, this gentleman found out for himself. 

Cold weather getting you down?

Hot festivals for the dropping temperatures in Colorado

Though the winter weather is far from delightful, Colorado knows a thing or two about enjoying oneself in all climates. Whether a nice outdoor music festival in the falling snow tickles your fancy, or coffin races are more up your ally, Colorado has a multitude of celebrations to guide you into the spring.

SnowDaze and Icelantic Winter on the Rocks

For those ready to shake it hard enough to make the snow on the Rockies feel like white sand on the beach, look no further than Snowball Music Festival and Icelantic Winter on the Rocks.

With last year’s performance exceeding expectations, Red Rocks Amphitheater decided to continue hosting one winter concert a year. Dubbed Icelantic Winter on the Rocks, this year’s all weather show will feature up and coming hip hop artist Macklemore and DJ Ryan Lewis. The two will take the stage on February 1st, and be supported by the likes of Major Lazer, Grouch and Eligh and Neelais.

After a month’s break to warm up, hit the outdoor action again with Winter Park’s Snowball Music Festival from March 8th-10th. Headliners include Pretty Lights, STS9, Kendrick Lamar and Big Gigantic, and the yet to be announced after parties always include some great tunes. General Admission tickets are still available for the show.

Snowdown Durango

Ever find yourself acting a bit out of character due to cabin fever? If so, head on down to Durango between the 1st and 5th of February to celebrate all the shenanigans that can happen during the cold, dark months of winter. Polar bear plunges, winter golf and arm wrestling are only a few of the fun-filled activites waiting for you in Southern Colorado.

Frozen Dead Guy

While March may come in like a lion and leave like a lamb in other parts of the world, in Colorado, it can be real cold and real wet. To keep the good times rolling in the rough weather, head to Nederland the weekend of March 2nd to participate in one of Colorado’s favorite past times: Frozen Dead Guy Days.

Though under new management, FDGD will still offer all the favorites like coffin rides, frozen T-shirt competitions, and of course, visiting good ol’ frozen Grandpa Bredo. The festival is a must if wacky celebrations, good tunes and great mirco brews tickle your fancy.

For more information on Colorado winter festivals, head to the Heidi Town website. Stay active, stay warm and for God sakes, stay fun during the colder months in colorful Colorado. 

Weekend distance action

From the Houston Marathon to the indoor track

This past weekend saw some great action in regards to professional, prep and collegiate running. With the winter months in full swing, and the end of cross country finally upon us, a good marathon and some great season openers on the track are exactly what distance fans need to get excited about the upcoming spring season.

Chevron Houston Marathon and ½ Marathon

Though the runners all came to compete, Mother Nature wasn’t going to make it easy on those toeing the line. Wind, rain and cold temperatures took a toll on times at the Chevron Houston Marathon and ½ Marathon race, but that didn’t stop the races from providing some great battles.

On the men’s side of the marathon, Bazu Worku of Ethiopia won his first major marathon in a time of 2:10:17. Worku is famous for holding the world junior marathon record, and having a sub 2:06 marathon PR. Andrew Carlson was the top American, placing 7th in a time of 2:17:16. He was followed by Scott Wietecha who placed 9th in 2:18:52.

The women’s side was won by Ethiopian Merima Mohammed in a time of 2:23:37. She was followed by country women Buzunesh Deba and Meskerem Assefa. Tara Moody was the first American finisher in 6th place, in a time of 2:39:10.

In the ½ marathon, Meb Keflezighi pulled out last minute due to the flu, but the men’s field still had a great showing.  2012 Houston ½ Champ Feysia Lilesa of Ethiopia repeated his victory, finishing in a time of 61:54. He was followed by Boston Champ Deriba Merga in a time of 62:00. Shadrack Biwott was the first American finshing 4th in 62:23, followed closely by former Oregon teammate Luke Puskedra in 62:32 finishing 5th.

On the women’s side, Ethiopia’s Mamitu Daska destroyed the field, winning by over two minutes in a time of 69:53. Lisa Uhl was the first American finisher in a time of 73:28, taking 6th place.

On the track

The two biggest track performances this weekend were given by Albertso Salazar-coached high schooler Mary Cain and Penn State senior and 2010 World Junior Silver Medalist Cas Loxsom. In a home opener, Loxsom destroyed the field running 1:46:98 for the 800m.

Since his stellar 2010 campaign, Loxsom has struggled with injury, so this is great news for mid-d fans. Cain, as well in dominate fashion, ran arguably the fastest American High School 3k ever, hitting 9:02 on University of Washington’s oversized indoor track. This time translates to a sub-10 2 mile which would crush the current record.

Stay tuned for more distance action from the tracks and the roads coming in the near future. 

Pages